Sinn Féin Calls for 2009 Review into Michael Shine to Be Published
Sinn Féin has urged the government to publish the 2009 review into the actions of former surgeon Michael Shine, amid increasing demands for a public inquiry into alleged sexual abuses. Michael Shine, now 93, was convicted of assaulting nine boys during two trials in 2017 and 2019. He served as a senior registrar at Our Lady of Lourdes Hospital in Drogheda, Co Louth, from 1964 to 1995.
David Cullinane, Sinn Féin’s health spokesperson, emphasized that the government should not delay further in making a decision on this matter. He expressed frustration with the government’s lack of action, calling for a more immediate response to the calls for transparency.
Taoiseach Simon Harris recently stated that the government would “reflect” on the possibility of a public inquiry. However, survivors of Shine’s alleged abuse have voiced their demands for a thorough investigation, many of whom believe the Medical Missionaries of Mary, the religious order that managed the hospital, was aware of the abuse for years.
Over 200 victims have already settled civil actions against the Medical Missionaries of Mary, highlighting the widespread impact of the alleged abuses. Belfast law firm Phoenix Law has formally requested that Minister for Justice Helen McEntee initiate a commission of investigation into Shine’s actions.
Cullinane strongly supports the calls for a public inquiry, stressing the need for a “victim-led approach.” He mentioned speaking with a victim who contributed to the 2009 review and expressed anger that the report has not been made public.
“It’s wrong that this victim hasn’t seen the review he contributed to,” Cullinane said, emphasizing the need for transparency. He called on Taoiseach Harris to meet with the victims and listen to their needs, advocating for the publication of the 2009 review.
“There has to be transparency in all of this,” Cullinane added. “The government must make a decision, and it must be done with the victims at the forefront.”
Cullinane criticized the Taoiseach’s recent comments about needing more time to “stocktake” the situation, questioning how much longer the victims would have to wait for justice and clarity.